https://ontologforum.com/index.php?action=history&feed=atom&title=OntologySummit2013_SurveySummary 2026-05-26T09:12:34Z Revision history for this page on the wiki MediaWiki 1.39.0 https://ontologforum.com/index.php?title=OntologySummit2013_SurveySummary&diff=2740&oldid=prev 2016-01-09T08:25:50Z

<p>Fix PurpleMediaWiki references</p> <p><b>New page</b></p><div><br /> This is a summary page generated from the answers to the Ontology Summit 2013 Survey.<br /> <br /> {| style=&quot;text-align: center&quot; class=&quot;wikitable sortable&quot;<br /> ! Question<br /> ! 15926Editor<br /> ! COLORE<br /> ! [[HyQue]]<br /> ! Macleod<br /> ! NCBO_BioPortal<br /> ! Ontohub<br /> ! [[OntologyTest|Ontology Test]]<br /> ! [[OntoQA]]<br /> ! OOPS<br /> ! OOR<br /> ! [[OpenLinkVirtuoso|Open Link Virtuoso]]<br /> ! [[RepOSE]]<br /> ! SigmaKEE<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Accept validation test sets or inputs?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Apply a style of ontological analysis to design?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess accuracy. correctness. and completeness of ontology terminological content?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess and enforce consistency and completeness of inverse relations?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess and enforce consistency and completeness of range and domain constraints?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess complexity of concept definitions (necessary and sufficient properties) and use of axioms?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess correctness or performance of an ontology design?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess inferencing completeness performance?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess inferencing time performance?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess or characterize breadth of domain coverage of an ontology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess or characterize depth or detail of domain coverage of an ontology?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess or characterize use considerations of ontology including licensing. training. cost. updating. software requirements. and security?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess or track user experience with ontology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess query precision and recall performance?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess query time performance?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess the inferencing power of an ontology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assess the reusability of a planned ontology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assure mathematically complete computability of ontology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Assure semantically adequate computability of ontology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Capture ontology errors during use?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Choose RDF support?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Choose extant core ontologies for reuse?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Choose extant top ontology for reuse?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Choose formal logic language?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Choose metaphysical methodology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Choose ontology language?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Compare and map between ontologies?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Compare domain coverage across ontologies?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Create mappings from ontologies to and from data and data sources?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Detect and guide use of multiple inheritance?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Detect violations of domain. referential. or semantic integrity?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Distinguish between conceptual and operational ontologies and objectives?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Enable adjustable query and inference performance?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Enable user to modify or extend ontology to address deficiencies?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Enforce proper use and coding of URIs?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Enforce proper use of conjunctions versus disjunctions?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Ensure kind-of nature and consistency of subclassing?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Ensure proper separation and coding of concepts and facts?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Ensure proper use and coding of RDF and Web resources?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Ensure proper use and coding of data types?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Ensure proper use and coding of relations?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Ensure proper use and coding of transitive relations?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Export ontology in different languages?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Facilitate framing a set of competency questions exemplifying ontology objectives?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Feedback on consistency of granularity and regularity of domain ontology structure?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Find ontologies with specific domain coverage?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Generate characteristic queries and tests?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Generate ontology application and performance requirements?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Generate ontology code from requirements specification?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Generate or enforce selected design patterns in ontology code?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Generate prototypical instances (individuals) to help verify class intent and class subsumption?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide and facilitate modularization of ontology?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide application of open world or closed world semantics?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide design to optimize normalization. factoring. and simplicity of ontology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide formulation of data and information requirements?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide formulation of domain scope and detail requirements?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide formulation of goodness of design requirements?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide formulation of interface requirements?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide formulation of level of effort requirements?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide formulation of semantic and reasoning requirements?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide ontology design for visualization?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide ontology design to achieve inferencing requirements?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide ontology design to achieve scalability requirements?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide ontology development per a quality assurance methodology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide or adjust ontology in accord with validation results?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide subclass versus class individual determinations?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide use of disjointness axioms?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide use of existential versus universal quantification in class restrictions?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Guide use of necessary and sufficient properties in concept definitions?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Identify age and use statistics of an ontology and its versions?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Identify frequency of use of ontology language features in an ontology?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Identify number and ratio of concepts. relations. and subclassing?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Integrate ontology with other information system resources?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Integrate ontology with other ontologies?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Integrate selected design patterns into an ontology design?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Manage lexical naming and annotation of ontology elements?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Mix ontology languages?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Monitor depth of subclassing consistency across a domain ontology?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Offer application patterns based on current ontology or design context?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Offer methodology patterns based on current ontology or design context?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Offer ontology language patterns based on current ontology or design context?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Offer other patterns based on current ontology or design context?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Optimize query and inference performance?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Organize and maintain a collection of related ontologies and ontology modules?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Organize and track the life cycle requirements and progression of an ontology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Overall. detect and correct coding errors or inconsistencies?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Produce the current terminological inferences of an ontology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Profile use of ontology elements during use?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Promote reuse of ontology?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Provide statistics on ontology versioning and use?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Rate ontologies on their popularity or review feedback?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Track ontology changes and control versions?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Validate instance data conforming to an ontology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Validate the intended functionality of software using the ontology?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Verify that ontology requirements are met?<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> | style=&quot;text-align:left&quot; | Verify that two ontologies are interoperable?<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{yes}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> | {{no}}<br /> |-<br /> |}<br /> &lt;skin&gt;vector&lt;/skin&gt;<br /> <br /> <br /> [[Category:OntologySummit]]<br /> [[Category:OntologySummit2013]]<br /> [[Category:OntologySummit2013_Survey]]</div>

imported>KennethBaclawski